Good Threads

Forums › General Discussion › Good Threads

ᎠяᏚuηshιηε Jul 20, 2012

In your opinion, what makes a good or successful thread/post? What do you look for in a thread? Is it a title? The player who posted it? Discuss, debate (although we've had way too much of that recently).
💀Pingas Jul 20, 2012

Uniqueness
Creativity
ㄎңձժø൰ (YW)🔫🔴🌆 Jul 20, 2012

It's the player who posts it. That's all anyone cares about.
GreenManXphile Jul 20, 2012

Fun. Intrigue. Gossip.
MOB 'N ROB Jul 20, 2012

I go for anything funny.
🐑Turf💔Warrior🐑 Jul 20, 2012

Pingas wrote:
Uniqueness
Creativity

This. And a good thread creator uses these two traits in most of their threads. They don't make a thread every day. Their threads are thought out and are interesting. Quality threads over a quantity of them.
████ⓙʘⓔ████ Jul 20, 2012

something that has a bit of thought in it, or something that gets all the forum involved, like UA's threads, i like them threads
ᎠяᏚuηshιηε Jul 20, 2012

UA's threads are great! I also like pretty much anything made by a vet.
🔰ਸᏧᏧ ℜⱥ༏Ҡℴ ц🔰 Jul 20, 2012

ㄎңձժø൰ (YW)🔫🔴🌆 wrote:
It's the player who posts it. That's all anyone cares about.

Grrrrr I hate to say it but this it 98% correct. I still think my thread was good😊
BellaItaliana Jul 20, 2012

All of the above & usually a thread will go further if it was created by someone who has made a name for themselves. That's just the way it is.
████ⓙʘⓔ████ Jul 20, 2012

🔰ਸᏧᏧ ℜⱥ༏Ҡℴ ц🔰 wrote:
ㄎңձժø൰ (YW)🔫🔴🌆 wrote:
It's the player who posts it. That's all anyone cares about.

Grrrrr I hate to say it but this it 98% correct. I still think my thread was good😊
yeah but you are a player who people like and care about
UnknownAssassin Jul 20, 2012

Hey, thanks above people about my threads. I try and make them a community based topic that generalizes the entire community so it can allow them in; of course I don't consciously think that but the meaning can imply that 'community wide based topic'. My advice is try and make them spread out over time. I have posted pretty recently and unfortunately not everyone gets involved in it so it dies but posting threads that are:

1) Community-wide based; minimum of majority-of-community-wide-based
2) Creative and unique by being different enough from other recent threads. After a thousand pages of about fifteen or so gd threads per page, repeats will happen. Recent being around a month or two.
3) Don't be sad if it doesn't get replies fast. Only threads that are negative like JX's gets attention fast. Exceptions are Angel of blades thread but it came from a situation, time and different vibed community over two years ago. Back when everything was simpler and no where near as many threads and people.
UnknownAssassin Jul 20, 2012

That is what I can think of for a foundation of a good thread that most of the community that comments will enough.
████ⓙʘⓔ████ Jul 20, 2012

yeah the JX thread lit up quicker than a lit match in a fireworks box
WestSider Jul 20, 2012

I din't know if mu threads are good or not, but I rarely make any. And my latest was 'Legend to be?' Did you guys like that one or not?
ᎠяᏚuηshιηε Jul 20, 2012

WestSider wrote:
I din't know if mu threads are good or not, but I rarely make any. And my latest was 'Legend to be?' Did you guys like that one or not?

It wasn't bad. I didn't participate, but it seemed popular for a while.
WestSider Jul 20, 2012

💉Ꭰя💊Ꮪuηshιηε💉 wrote:
WestSider wrote:
I din't know if mu threads are good or not, but I rarely make any. And my latest was 'Legend to be?' Did you guys like that one or not?

It wasn't bad. I didn't participate, but it seemed popular for a while.
Cool thanks.